I’ve come across something called intuitive eating. The idea, it seems, is that there is just food, not good food vs. bad food; and that if we listen, our bodies will tell us what to eat and when and how much.
I like this approach for its appeal to nature — that our bodies are designed in such a way as to cue us to eat, even to suggest what kind of food we need at the moment. And that if we really pay attention, we will learn that we don’t necessarily want as many potato chips as we think we do, and that if we get all the messy psychological garbage about food out of our heads, we might find we really do want an apple instead.
I think it’s obvious that dealing with the psychological stuff isn’t always possible through intuition alone — for some folks therapy or other external help might be necessary before this approach can work.
I am not sure that I can live with the idea that there is no bad food.
However, that may depend on what we mean by bad food.
I agree that it’s wrong to consider food choices sinful, or make food choices in order to punish or reward ourselves.
But I do think there are harmful food options, harmless but non-beneficial options, and beneficial options, to varying degrees.
If you have a food allergy, eating that food is a harmful option.
Eating donuts may be harmful or harmless, depending on how they were made and what research you believe about the effects of processed sugars and flours and artificial ingredients and such. But unless they’re very unusual donuts, they’re not beneficial. Not nutritionally, anyway.
A donut now and then in moderation? Sure — why not? Preferably a donut made with good ingredients and good processes.
One of the things that I hate about the modern food industry is the divorcing of taste and appearance from the substance — making oranges more orange, meat more red, regardless of what’s inside or how fresh it really is; inventing artificial ingredients that have appealing tastes and slapping them onto otherwise empty foods; and so on.
Good food should look and taste good — bad food should look and taste bad.